Emmalie Gabel
Professor Kelly
English 120 12:40-2
25 October 2012
How Safe Is Bottled Water?
While reading the article “Some bottled water toxicity shown to exceed law” written by Jane Kay and published in the San Francisco Chronicle, I got very worried about the water I am drinking. In this article Jane Kay talks about the toxins found in bottled water that were bought from a local Wal-Mart. Her main point in the piece was bottled water does not always maintain the quality that the company’s advertise, but sometimes contain toxins that exceed state safety standards. I agree with her main point we don’t know where water is really coming from we just buy water from what the advertisements tell us it comes from, for example does Fuji water really come from Fuji? Does Voss water really come from Norway? You may think that you are getting “better” water because you pay more for it, but the question is are you really? Is bottled water any better than tap water?
The Environmental Working Group conducted the research on this experiment, they tested 10 different bottled water brands from a local Wal-Mart. They found that Wal-Mart’s Sam’s Choice bottled water and 4 other brands were contaminated with bacteria. Wal-Mart is not just selling us water with bacteria and trihalomethanes (cancer-causing chemicals) they are breaking the law. “Proposition 65 the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1995 states that in California the standard is 10 parts per billion, and considering that Sam’s Choice water comes from the Las Vegas water supply which is under federal standard in 80 parts per billion…”, they are selling us water that is breaking the law of California and could cause cancer and reproductive damage. When the EWG brought their finding to Wal-Mart with the intent to sue them, Shannon Frederick, senior communications manager stated “We’re puzzled by he EWG’s findings”, clearly no knowing what is in the water. From the study EWG found byproducts, bromodichloromethane and carcinogen in Sam’s Choice water exceeding the state level. They also found caffeine, Tylenol, arsenic, radioactive isotopes, nitrates and ammonia.
With all that said what do you think is safer? The Food and Drug Administration requires bottled water to meet the same standards as tap water from public system. This means that we are paying for tap water to be bottled up for us. Why pay more money when you can buy a reusable water bottle, you would save money and the environment. “Americans drank more than 9 billion gallons in 2007. Typical cost is 3.79 per gallon, that is 1,900 times the cost of public tap water.” That’s a lot of money we could be saving there. Lets not just think financially but lets think environmentally, “green campaigns have focused on steering away from bottled water because manufacturing, transporting and sending unrecycled bottles to the landfill use natural resources and create an environmental burden.” With that said we could save our planet from massive landfills of unrecycled water bottles if we just by a reusables one. Think of all the space we can save and all of the pollution we can neglect if we just drink tap water that is the same thing as bottled water. After all of the research and the facts shown to me I will choose to drink tap water and put it in a reusable bottle instead of buying bottled water .
No comments:
Post a Comment